
WAN 2.6 vs WAN 2.5: я сравнил последнюю версию ИИ с предыдущей
Этот текст написан в Сообществе, в нем сохранены авторский стиль и орфография
Я решил сравнить все версии WAN: 2.5, 2.6 и 2.6 Flash, чтобы понять, какая реально работает лучше.
Для теста я использовал одну и ту же картинку и одинаковые промпты для всех версий и снял видео с результатами.
Исходные данные
Промпт
In the original photo, Snegurochka is in the foreground and Ded Moroz is behind her. Ded Moroz smirks and throws a small snowball at Snegurochka. The snowball hits her shoulder, scattering into a cloud of snow dust. She flinches slightly and slowly turns her head over her shoulder towards him. Her serious expression changes to playfully displeased, she coquettishly squints her eyes and her lips say: «Нет, Дед Мороз». From her breath in the frost, a light steam rises.
Негатив
worst quality, low quality, blurry, JPEG artifacts, watermark, ugly, deformed, extra fingers, poorly drawn hands, poorly drawn face, face morphing, malformed limbs, static, frozen frame, motionless, cartoon, anime, 3d render, CGI, illustration, plastic skin
Вот что получилось
Вместо вывода
Вы сами всё видите. Это далеко не первая моя попытка заставить WAN 2.6 выдавать кинематографичную картинку, но похоже, его учили на китайских аниме — и в итоге результат выглядит сыро. При этом он поддерживает длинные промпты и вроде как имеет встроенный LLM, но качество всё равно оставляет вопросы.
Хотя 15 секундные видео все равно часто склоняют выбор в пользу WAN 2.6
Для сравнения
WAN 2.6 + улучшенные промпт через Sixio
Photorealistic cinematic video, professional cinematography, high quality, 4K resolution, smooth natural motion, realistic inertia, physically plausible movement, stable consistent identity from reference image, cinematic color grading, no flickering, no morphing, lifelike details
SCENE BASIS
IDENTITY: preserve the facial features and appearance of both characters from the original image, stable identity, no face change, no age change
CHARACTERS:
Woman1 (Snegurochka): ~25 years old, long light hair braided into two thick braids, beautiful face with a serious expression, dressed in a luxurious white dress with blue patterns and fur trim, wearing a silver crown (kokoshnik) with precious stones on her head. Stands in the foreground.
Man1 (Ded Moroz): elderly man with a long white beard and hair, in a richly decorated blue-white fur coat and hat, holding an icy staff with a blue tip in his hand. Stands in the background.
Interaction: She in the foreground on the right, he in the background on the left.
LOCATION: Winter landscape by a frozen river, with beautiful ancient wooden churches visible in the background. Clear frosty day, pure snow everywhere.
LIGHTING: Bright, cold daylight from the low winter sun, creating long shadows on the snow.
ATMOSPHERE: Fairy-tale, majestic, Russian winter, epic.
[00:00–00:02]
CAMERA: medium shot, static.
MOTION: Man1 in the background slyly smirks and makes a quick, short hand movement, throwing a small snowball at Woman1, natural motion. The snowball hits her right shoulder and scatters into a cloud of light snow dust.
SFX: quiet whistle of the flying snowball, soft smack on impact.
[00:02–00:05]
CAMERA: smooth, slow zoom in on Woman1’s face.
MOTION: Woman1 slightly flinches from the impact, realistic inertia. Then slowly and gracefully turns her head over her shoulder toward Man1. Her serious expression changes to playfully displeased, she coquettishly squints her eyes. A light cloud of steam escapes from her slightly parted lips in the frost, hair and clothes move naturally.
WOMAN1: «Нет, Дед Мороз» (speaks quietly, with playful reproach, Russian language, synchronized lip movements).
SFX: light female sigh, quiet background sound of winter wind.
STYLE masterpiece, best quality, highres, photorealistic, cinematic, 4K, detailed skin texture, intricate details, sharp focus, professional color grading, film grain, lifelike
NEGATIVE worst quality, low quality, blurry, blurry details, JPEG artifacts, overexposed, washed out gray tones, grainy, pixelated, noise, glitch, artifacts, watermark, subtitles, text overlay, logo, ugly, incomplete, static, frozen frame, motionless, still image, deformed, disfigured, bad anatomy, extra fingers, poorly drawn hands, poorly drawn face, malformed limbs, fused fingers, extra limbs, duplicated body parts, walking backwards, reversed motion, face morphing, identity change, different person, changing face, cartoon, pixar, disney, anime, 3d animation, CGI, plastic skin, doll-like, illustration, drawing, oversmoothed skin, stylized, cluttered background, desynchronized lip movement, mismatched audio, frozen mouth, no lip movement during speech
А вот так справился Grok (с тем же оригинальным промптом) Качественно и дешево…
А как вы делаете промпты для WAN 2.6?

































